Avoiding Middlemen: How eCommerce Businesses Can Verify Direct Manufacturers

Sourcing products for e-commerce, especially from China, is a crucial process that directly affects costs, product quality, and scalability. Many suppliers on Alibaba and other sourcing platforms claim to be manufacturers, but in reality, they are trade companies acting as middlemen. These intermediaries add markups, restrict communication with actual producers, and may not have direct control over product quality.

To maximize profit margins and maintain product consistency, it’s essential to determine whether you are working with a factory or a trade company. This guide will walk you through key indicators, verification strategies, and the pros and cons of trade companies in e-commerce.

Why It Matters: The Impact on E-commerce

For e-commerce sellers, working with a factory instead of a trade company can significantly impact business operations:

• Cost Savings: Direct factory relationships eliminate middlemen fees, resulting in lower per-unit costs.
• Better Customization: Factories can modify designs, materials, and production processes to suit your brand’s needs.
• Reliable Scaling: Trade companies may struggle with order volume fluctuations, while factories can scale production efficiently.
• Improved Quality Control: Direct communication with the factory ensures consistent quality and faster issue resolution.

Now, let’s examine how to differentiate between a factory and a trade company.

Catalog Clues: How Product Offerings Reveal a Supplier’s Identity

1. Factories Specialize in One Category

Manufacturing requires specialized equipment, certifications, and expertise. Because of this, real factories focus on a single niche and refine their production processes within that specialization.

Examples:

• A wireless earbuds factory may also produce Bluetooth headphones and microphones, but not power banks or LED lights.
• A skincare manufacturer may offer serums, lotions, and creams, but not makeup, hair care, and essential oils.
• An electronics factory will manufacture either audio equipment or charging devices, but not both.

If a supplier’s catalog includes multiple unrelated categories, it’s likely a trade company.

2. Large, Diverse Catalogs Indicate a Trade Company

Trade companies act as intermediaries between multiple factories, allowing them to offer a broad range of products. If a supplier provides a mix of kitchenware, clothing, electronics, and pet products, they are almost certainly a trade company.

3. Lack of Company Details Suggests a Trade Company

Factories are typically proud of their production capabilities and showcase details like:

• Factory photos
• Machinery used in manufacturing
• Certifications such as ISO, CE, and GMP

Trade companies often lack these details and instead display generic office photos or product showrooms.

Geographical Indicators: Understanding Factory Locations

1. Supplier Locations and Industry Clusters

In China, different regions specialize in specific industries. Factories are usually located in manufacturing hubs, while trade companies operate near financial centers.

Common Industry Hubs:

• Electronics: Guangdong Province (Shenzhen, Dongguan, Guangzhou)
• Beauty & Skincare: Guangdong Province (Guangzhou), Shanghai
• Apparel & Textiles: Zhejiang, Jiangsu, Guangzhou

If a supplier claims to be an electronics factory but is based in Hangzhou or Shanghai, they are likely a trade company.

2. Trade Companies Cluster Near Trade Centers

Unlike factories, trade companies often set up offices in major financial hubs such as Shanghai and Hangzhou. These areas focus on finance and trade, not manufacturing.

3. Mapping Supplier Locations for Verification

A quick Google search or Alibaba check can reveal supplier locations. Factories typically cluster in industrial zones, while trade companies are scattered in multiple locations.

Certifications & Technical Knowledge: Key Verification Steps

1. Cross-Checking Certifications

Factories hold official certifications under their company name (e.g., FDA, CE, GMP, ISO). Trade companies often provide documents that belong to a different company—the actual manufacturer.

How to verify:

• Request copies of factory certifications.
• Compare the company name on the document with their Alibaba listing or website.
• If names don’t match, it’s a trade company.

2. Technical Knowledge and Response Times

Factories have in-depth product knowledge, while trade companies rely on factory contacts for information. A simple way to test them is by asking detailed technical questions about:

• Materials used
• Production processes
• Compliance standards

Factories answer quickly, while trade companies delay responses because they must check with the manufacturer.

3. Direct Communication with Engineers

Factories have engineers or production managers who can discuss technical specifications immediately. Trade companies hesitate or avoid letting buyers speak directly with factory personnel.

Trade Company Tactics to Watch Out For

1. Office Showrooms Instead of Factories

Some trade companies invite buyers to China and take them to an office showroom instead of a production facility. Red flags include:

• Refusing to disclose factory details.
• Making excuses to delay a factory visit.
• Showing only office spaces and product samples.

2. Struggling to Answer Technical Questions

If a supplier frequently says, “I need to check with the factory,” they are likely a trade company. Real manufacturers know their processes inside and out.

How Alibaba Helps Trade Companies Appear as Factories

Alibaba allows trade companies to market themselves as manufacturers, making differentiation harder. Trade company tactics include:

• Paying for high Alibaba rankings.
• Using generic factory photos (sometimes stock images).
• Employing professional sales teams fluent in English to build trust.

Tip: Use “Verified Supplier” status as a reference but still conduct due diligence.

Pros and Cons of Working with a Trade Company

Pros:

• Useful in fragmented industries where factories lack direct sales teams (e.g., kitchenware, textiles, pet products).
• Can bundle products from multiple factories, useful for small brands needing variety.
• Offer packaging and branding services, valuable for private label brands.

Cons:

• Higher costs due to added middleman fees.
• Limited customization since trade companies don’t control manufacturing.
• Slower responses and less control over quality assurance.

Best Practices for E-commerce Brands

1. Vet Suppliers Thoroughly

• Analyze their product catalog.
• Check their location in relation to manufacturing hubs.
• Verify certifications and technical expertise.

2. Test Responsiveness

• Ask technical questions.
• Request factory photos and videos.
• Schedule a video call to see their production facilities live.

3. Order Samples Before Committing

A sample order can reveal product quality, shipping times, and communication efficiency.

4. Consider Third-Party Inspections

Before placing large orders, hire a third-party inspection service to verify the factory’s legitimacy.

‍

Conclusion

Detecting whether you're working with a trade company or a factory is essential for maintaining cost efficiency and scaling an e-commerce business. While trade companies can be useful in certain industries, direct factory relationships lead to better pricing, customization, and reliability.

By following these strategies, e-commerce sellers can avoid unnecessary middlemen, negotiate better prices, and build a direct, profitable factory relationship.

‍